Advertisement
Sri Lanka’s relationship with China has been a controversial dialogue throughout the final decade, dominating each home and worldwide political conversations. The strengthening relationship between the island nation and the rising international energy has been largely financial. Yet it’s fairly clear that Sri Lanka’s closest neighbor, India, and the United States are diligently monitoring these developments in the China-Sri Lanka relationship.
China has been a significant financial accomplice for Sri Lanka. Beijing’s help has been essential in saving the poorly performing Sri Lankan financial system throughout the final three years. At the similar time, Sri Lanka is compelled to not antagonize India, the closest neighbor of the island, with which Sri Lanka’s relationship runs deep and much again. The India-Sri Lanka relationship is vastly completely different than its ties with China.
With India, Sri Lanka’s relationship throughout the submit-colonial period goes properly past financial relations. India has been extraordinarily influential in Sri Lanka’s home politics. For occasion, India performed a key function in introducing the 13th Amendment to the structure of Sri Lanka, which introduced energy devolution to the nation to offer an answer to Sri Lanka’s ethnic battle. Concerns that ethnic battle, notably the issues of Tamil minorities dwelling in Sri Lanka, are sometimes amongst the political discussions in India, particularly in Tamil Nadu. In 1987, India despatched its military to combat in opposition to the home terrorist group LTTE, which demanded a separate nation for Tamils in Sri Lanka. The mission is commonly thought of a failure, and the then-Indian premier, Rajiv Gandhi, known as again the Indian military given their failure to defeat the LTTE. Later, the LTTE killed Gandhi, claiming revenge for the operations in opposition to the LTTE. The struggle between the Sri Lankan authorities and the LTTE led to 2009. However, the considerations about energy devolution to the Tamil minority stay unaddressed and India has been persistently pushing Sri Lanka for full implementation of the 13th Amendment. Most not too long ago, the similar concern was raised by India’s External Affairs Minister S. Jaishankar throughout his go to to Sri Lanka in early 2021.
China’s relationship with Sri Lanka has been vastly completely different, due partly to China’s larger distance from the island. While China has been an ally of Sri Lanka in the submit-independence interval, its involvement in Sri Lanka’s home affairs has been minimal. The development of the China-Sri Lanka relationship is a latest phenomenon and one largely anchored on financial and monetary ties. However, lately, army and political relations between the two international locations have additionally grown.
The Rise of Economic Relations With China
Upon upgrading to a center-revenue nation, Sri Lanka has been closely uncovered to extreme and recurrent Balance of Payment (BOP) crises. This compelled successive governments to hunt options to flee from financial troubles, which resulted in stronger financial ties with China – and an elevated reliance on China in Sri Lanka’s growth course of.
While there are numerous obscure claims about the strengthening financial relationship between Sri Lanka and China, which typically consists of claims resembling Sri Lanka turning into a cat’s-paw state for China, it’s critical and important to analyze the avenues by means of which bilateral financial relations have developed and the underlying causes. While a lot dialogue of the rising China-Sri Lanka relationship has targeted on the elevated reliance on Chinese loans, which is commonly (and inaccurately) depicted as Sri Lanka falling right into a Chinese debt entice, rising bilateral financial relations go far past debt. The blooming China-Sri Lanka financial relationship, which Colombo appears to cherish as a blessing presently, is happening by means of three important avenues: debt, funding, and commerce. Therefore, proscribing the focus of Sri Lanka’s reliance on China to merely Chinese loans downplays the rising relationship between the two international locations.
Diplomat Brief
Weekly Newsletter
N
Get briefed on the story of the week, and creating tales to observe throughout the Asia-Pacific.
Get the Newsletter
In phrases of public debt, China over the final decade and a half has been the second-largest overseas lender for Sri Lanka. Several massive infrastructure growth initiatives, together with the Colombo-Katunayake expressway, which connects the important business metropolis and the main airport; Hambantota port; and the second worldwide airport of the nation, Mattala Airport, all had been funded by Chinese loans. This of course has been a a lot-mentioned phenomenon, used to strengthen claims of debt-entice diplomacy.
Advertisement
By the finish of 2019, China owned a bit over 10 p.c of Sri Lanka’s excellent overseas debt inventory. While most of these money owed consist of loans obtained for giant-scale infrastructure growth initiatives, not too long ago obtained Chinese loans had been for budgetary and BOP help. On high of that, in early 2021, the Sri Lankan authorities obtained a 10 billion renminbi (RMB) foreign money swap facility from China to sort out the ongoing overseas foreign money scarcity. These point out Sri Lanka’s altering relationship to Chinese Loans and rising reliance on mortgage devices resembling Foreign Currency Term Financing Facilities and swaps to save lots of the nation from a extreme Balance of Payment disaster, and even from defaulting on its debt.
Sri Lanka obtained a Foreign Currency Term Financing Facility (FTFF) of $1 billion from the China Development Bank in 2018, and one other $500 million in March 2020. Most not too long ago, in early April 2021, Sri Lanka signed one other settlement with the CDB to acquire $500 million as an FTFF. These mortgage amenities, together with the foreign money swap supplied in March 2021, point out that Sri Lanka is closely counting on China to keep away from exterior sector vulnerabilities (i.e., BOP points).
Secondly, equally to Chinese lending, over the previous decade, Chinese investments have additionally performed an important function in Sri Lanka’s financial growth. During the decade of 2010-2020, China has been the largest overseas investor in Sri Lanka. These investments embody two controversial initiatives: the Colombo Port City Project and the funding in Hambantota Port by the China Merchants Port Company. Under the port metropolis challenge, 116 hectares of reclaimed land in Colombo was leased to CHEC Colombo Port City (Pvt) Ltd, owned by a Chinese state-owned enterprise for 99 years. The port metropolis challenge has drawn a lot controversy in the latest previous. The opposition claims that proposed laws meant to facilitate funding in the port metropolis threatens Sri Lanka’s sovereignty.
Data from Board of Investment, Sri Lanka.
Third, throughout the final two years, China has turn into the high import accomplice of Sri Lanka, surpassing India, which had lengthy been Sri Lanka’s largest supply of imports. In 2020, China continued to be the largest items exporter to Sri Lanka regardless of the heavy import restrictions imposed by the Sri Lankan authorities to manage overseas foreign money outflows. This coverage, nonetheless, doesn’t appear to have affected China as a lot because it impacted India. Chinese imports had been lowered by eight p.c in 2020, whereas in distinction, imports from India went down by roughly 19 p.c.
The purpose for is the kind of items imported from China. Over the years, China has turn into the main supply from which Sri Lanka obtains uncooked materials for textiles and clothes. These, in flip, are the main merchandise exports for Sri Lanka; 45 p.c of Sri Lankan exports are textiles and apparels. The availability of textile uncooked supplies, resembling yarn and material, at a low value from Chinese suppliers seems to be the main purpose for Sri Lanka to import these items from China as an alternative of from India or Pakistan, which beforehand was once main importers of textile supplies to Sri Lanka.
India’s Economic Role in Sri Lanka
What is fascinating to note is how Sri Lanka’s financial relationship with India had progressed by means of these similar three avenues: debt, funding and commerce. India has by no means been a significant lender for Sri Lanka, nor can they lend to Sri Lanka in a capability just like China. Unlike China, India runs on a commerce deficit above $100 billion and runs into overseas trade points once in a while. This means India’s lending capability is restricted and their lending help will largely be based mostly on export credit.
Author consolidation based mostly on knowledge from the External Resource Department of Sri Lanka (ERD).
However, up till this yr, Sri Lanka had been counting on India to handle its overseas trade issues by acquiring foreign money swaps. Early this yr, although, India refused to increase the time period of its foreign money swap settlement with Sri Lanka, quoting considerations about Sri Lanka’s financial local weather. New Delhi stated it was unwilling to increase the swap facility until Sri Lanka entered into an IMF program.
Advertisement
To many, nonetheless, this appeared like retaliation for Sri Lanka’s sudden reversal on a deal to lease an element of the East Container Terminal (ECT) of Colombo port to the Indian enterprise conglomerate Adani group. Having promised earlier to lease out 51 p.c of the ECT to India, amid rising opposition from nationalist teams, the Sri Lankan authorities abruptly reversed course, claiming they’d determined to not lease the terminal.
This could possibly be a priority for India for a number of causes. First, 85 p.c of the Colombo International Container Terminal (CICT), which is the largest terminal of Colombo port, is managed by the China Merchant Port Company, which operates as a three way partnership with Sri Lanka Port Authority (SLPA). This deal was additionally inked beneath a Rajapaksa authorities, a number of years again. Second, Hambantota port was leased to China for 99 years and the deal went forward regardless of the controversies surrounding it. Against such a backdrop, India inevitably feels that they’re being undermined or ignored in mild of the rising presence of China.
However, Sri Lanka’s Cabinet has cleared the West Container Terminal (WCT) of Colombo port to be developed as a 35-year three way partnership with India’s Adani Group and its native accomplice, John Keells Holdings PLC, in addition to with an funding from Japan.
This brings us to the query of funding. Sri Lanka has acquired little or no FDI from India and that quantity appears even smaller compared to the funding from China throughout the previous decade. Additionally, the quantity of Chinese investments in Sri Lanka has been state-led and ruled by strategic pursuits. The two greatest examples of such funding are Colombo Port City and Hambantota port, each of which serve strategic functions for China. India, on the different hand, has made no such investments in Sri Lanka. Perhaps the solely funding India has made that’s of strategic curiosity is the Lanka Indian Oil Company, a subsidiary of state-owned Indian Oil Company, which controls roughly 15 p.c of the auto gasoline provide in Sri Lanka. This funding was facilitated in 2003 as an element of the then-authorities’s coverage to interrupt the state monopoly in gasoline distribution. Since then there have been little or no strategic FDI coming into Sri Lanka from India.
Trade has been the strongest half of the financial relationship between India and Sri Lanka. Historically, India has been Sri Lanka’s largest supply of imports, till China surpassed India not too long ago. The very first free commerce settlement (FTA) of Sri Lanka was signed with India in 1998 and curiously, the Indo-Sri Lanka Free Trade Agreement (ISFTA) was the very first FTA for India as properly. This FTA has been in impact for a bit over 20 years now and there have been a number of efforts to increase the FTA to an Economic and Technology Cooperation Agreement. However, these negotiations failed given the sturdy opposition of nationalist teams and professionals, in addition to a regime change in Sri Lanka.
While there are points relating to the Indo-Sri Lanka FTA, together with considerations on non-tariff boundaries imposed by India, greater than 70 p.c of Sri Lanka’s export to India are routed by means of the FTA, using the tariff-free entry. India on the different hand takes little benefit of the FTA advantages. As per present knowledge, solely 10-20 p.c of Indian exports are routed by means of the ISFTA to Sri Lanka. What is fascinating to notice is that China has overtaken India as the largest exporter to Sri Lanka with out having an FTA with Sri Lanka, and thus with none tariff-free entry.
Data from Sri Lanka Customs
China turning into the largest importer to Sri Lanka, together with the main provider of uncooked materials to Sri Lanka’s textile business, has considerably elevated Sri Lanka’s reliance on China the commerce entrance. This could have been seen as much less of a priority in comparison with rising reliance on Chinese loans; nonetheless, the latest choice of Sri Lanka to acquire a 10 billion RMB credit score swap from China was a transparent indication of rising Chinese affect tied to the rise of Chinese imports.
However, Sri Lanka’s exports to China have didn’t match the development of Chinese exports to Sri Lanka. In 2020, Sri Lanka’s exports to China amounted to simply 2.three p.c of whole exports, whereas exports to India represented 6.1 p.c of whole export. Sri Lanka depends extra on India as an export market, particularly as most of its merchandise can enter India tariff-free, due to their FTA.
Balance of Power
Currently, the Sri Lankan financial system is grappling with critical exterior sector points. The nation is struggling to fulfill its overseas debt repayments on account of inadequate overseas foreign money inflows. With the COVID-19 pandemic, the state of affairs worsened, largely on account of the vital loss of tourism earnings, which represent a significant overseas foreign money influx for Sri Lanka. On the different hand, Sri Lanka’s overseas debt reimbursement obligations stay the similar.
Taken collectively, the circumstances have put Sri Lanka in a susceptible place. The greatest concern is that Sri Lanka can not deal with its issues as merely a home political problem. Tackling Sri Lanka’s exterior sector vulnerabilities, together with the scarcity of overseas foreign money, would require help from exterior events, whether or not China, India, the United States, and even worldwide organizations resembling the IMF or World Bank.
Advertisement
Thus far, Sri Lanka has excessively relied on China to sort out its exterior sector vulnerabilities whereas financial relations with India appear to stay stagnant. At the similar time, Sri Lanka tries to not irritate India. Against this backdrop, Sri Lanka is now struggling onerous to stability between China, India, and home nationalists, all the whereas making an attempt to save lots of the nation from a possible financial disaster. Thus far, it doesn’t look simple.
