Maybe it’s going to wind up on eBay.
Frank Trapper/Getty Images
The annual Golden Globe Awards, which honor each TV and motion pictures, have by no means had the flash of the Oscars, and for many years that did not appear to matter. For many, the Globes had been one other likelihood to see dressed-up stars accumulate shiny trophies and thank their brokers. But in 2021, each the Golden Globes and the Hollywood Foreign Press Association, the group that offers them out, are below hearth. NBC has introduced it will not televise the present in 2022, and actor Tom Cruise reportedly has despatched again three of his awards.
Here’s a take a look at the Globes’ tangled historical past and unsure future. (We’ve reached out to the HFPA for remark however have not but heard again.)
Entertain your mind with the best information from streaming to superheroes, memes to video video games.
What’s the controversy?
Well, it is not only a single controversy. The Hollywood Foreign Press Association is not precisely the distinguished Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences. It’s a tiny group of journalists and photographers, based in 1943, with members from greater than 50 international locations, although lively members should dwell in Southern California. In February, the Los Angeles Times printed a scorching story about issues inside the group, and since then the Golden Globes, the group’s excessive-profile awards present, has been within the highlight.
No Black voting members
The Hollywood Foreign Press Association is a small group of simply 87 critics, and the Los Angeles Times report stated the group has no Black voting members. Its most up-to-date checklist of nominations did not embody a number of Black-led Oscar contenders, together with Da 5 Bloods, Ma Rainey’s Black Bottom and Judas and the Black Messiah.
The membership was questioned in different methods, too — the Times stated “relatively few (HFPA members) work full-time for major overseas outlets.”
Former group president’s e mail
Recently, former President Philip Berk was expelled from the HFPA for sharing with group members an article that described Black Lives Matter as a “racist hate group.” He later stated he “forwarded it as a point of information.”
Berk, 88, wasn’t only a random member. He was president of the group for eight years and a member for 44 years. And actor Brendan Fraser stated Berk groped him in 2003. Berk denied that issues occurred as Fraser described and stated he “pinched (Fraser) in jest.”
Lavish junket
In 2019, 30 members of the group had been flown to France for a luxurious journey to the set of the Netflix present Emily in Paris, which later obtained two shocking Golden Globes nominations. Insider.com reported the journey was paid for by Paramount Network, the present’s unique producers, although the HFPA stated in an announcement to Insider the group paid for the airfare for its members on that journey.
In an opinion piece that ran within the Guardian, one of many Emily in Paris writers stated “it never occurred to me that our show would be nominated.” That similar author identified that the Golden Globes snubbed the far more extremely acclaimed I May Destroy You, which has a predominantly Black British forged. The query being requested appears clear: Were the producers in a position to purchase Golden Globe nominations by pampering the international critics?
The Emily in Paris junket is not a one-off sort of occasion. The Times report stated HFPA members “are routinely granted exclusive access to Hollywood power players, invited to junkets in exotic locales, put up in five-star hotels and, as Globes nominations near, lavished with gifts, dinners and star-studded parties.”
Payments to members
The LA Times report additionally stated the HFPA, a tax-exempt nonprofit, pays its members in ways in which may violate IRS pointers.
“HFPA members collected nearly $2 million in payments from the group in its fiscal year ending in June 2020 for serving on various committees and performing other tasks — more than double the level three years earlier,” the LA Times reported.
The Times wrote that “by the end of 2020, the association was collectively paying nearly $100,000 a month to members serving on more than a dozen different committees.” The movie and tv academies, the teams operating the Oscars and Emmys, do not pay their members to serve on committees, the report stated.
The HFPA responded to the newspaper by saying its compensation relies on market charges, and that funds are “vetted by a professional nonprofit compensation consultant and outside counsel, where appropriate.”
The New York Times spoke to an legal professional who stated that regardless that the group is as a 501(c) (6) tax-exempt group, and as such should profit the business in a roundabout way, funds aren’t essentially towards the regulation, as long as they’re thought-about cheap. After wanting over the HFPA’s tax return, the legal professional informed the publication, “There are some healthy numbers on there, but not really beyond the pale.”
The 2022 telecast
NBC introduced on May 10 that it will not air the Golden Globes in 2022, as had been beforehand deliberate, however famous that the HFPA has stated it is engaged on reforms. “Assuming the organization executes on its plan, we are hopeful we will be in a position to air the show in January 2023,” NBC’s assertion stated.
That’s an enormous loss for the Globes. The LA Times report famous that “last fiscal year, the organization pulled in $27.4 million from (NBC), up from $3.64 million in fiscal 2016-2017, according to a budget document.”
The HFPA response — and a backlash
In May the group introduced plans to alter issues. Suggested adjustments included including extra members with a concentrate on range; including new administrative positions, together with a chief range and inclusion officer; including an oversight board; and proscribing presents.
Members voted for the reforms, however the adjustments weren’t sufficient for a lot of. Time’s Up, a gaggle that fights sexual harassment at work, plus a gaggle of 100 public-relations companies, stated the HFPA wasn’t shifting quick sufficient and that the reforms weren’t particular sufficient. The stress put the HFPA again to work and it nows plans to full reforms by early August.
Studio response
Netflix, Amazon Studios and WarnerMedia have already refused to work with the HFPA till adjustments are made. And the adjustments the HFPA first proposed did not go far sufficient to fulfill these studios.
Netflix co-CEO and Chief Content Officer Ted Sarandos stated the group is “stopping all activities” with the HFPA till “more meaningful changes are made.” As The Hollywood Reporter reported, Netflix obtained extra nominations and wins than every other studio or community on the 2021 Golden Globes in February.
“We have not been working with the HFPA since these issues were first raised, and like the rest of the industry, we are awaiting a sincere and significant resolution before moving forward,” Amazon Studios chief Jennifer Salke stated in an announcement issued May 7.
WarnerMedia, dwelling of HBO, additionally stated the corporate would not work with the HFPA till “changes are implemented.”
What are the celebrities saying?
Actor Tom Cruise is returning the three Golden Globes he is received over time, Deadline reported. The report did not give particulars as to what precisely Cruise was objecting to or if he included a message, however the actor is not precisely identified for social protests, so that is novel for him.
It’s unknown if different stars have returned their Golden Globes, however lots of them do appear to favor HFPA reforms. Back in February, when Time’s Up tweeted an HFPA-associated message saying that “a cosmetic fix isn’t enough,” greater than a dozen celebrities shared the message. That checklist consists of Jennifer Aniston, Mark Ruffalo, Kerry Washington, Amy Schumer, Simon Pegg, Busy Phillips, Dakota Johnson, Patton Oswalt, Laura Dern, Alyssa Milano and extra.
Director Ava DuVernay tweeted an announcement noting the awards the HFPA provides out “unfortunately” matter so far as making it simpler for winners to finance their tasks.
“Therefore, everyone must have balanced access and consideration so that the playing field can be more equitable for artists of all kinds, colors and cultures,” DuVernay stated partially.
Scarlett Johansson is also urging the movie business to pull again from the HFPA. In an announcement to Variety, she stated that for years, she refused to take part within the group’s information conferences as a result of, “In the past, this has often meant facing sexist questions and remarks by certain HFPA members that bordered on sexual harassment.”
And Mark Ruffalo stated he did not really feel pleased with profitable Golden Globes. “It’s discouraging to see the HFPA, which has gained prominence and profited handsomely from their involvement with filmmakers and actors, resist the change that is being asked of them from many of the groups that have been most disenfranchised by their culture of secrecy and exclusion,” he stated in an announcement to Deadline.
This battle will not be over anytime quickly, as choices concerning the destiny of the 2022 awards present — now with no community — will want to be made. Stay tuned.
New motion pictures popping out in 2021: Netflix, Marvel and extra
See all images
